Last summer, I discovered Doctor Who and declared it the best show ever. I mean, it had everything! It was a time-traveling love story for gosh sakes! The Doc was quippy and clever, the monsters were cool, and the story arcs were often breathtaking. While the Series 3 finale may have ended on a bit of an awkward note, I was still on board 100%
Now, after series 4 has come and gone, I’m not too sure. Oh, sure, it’s still a consistently fun time and I will be psyched for the Christmas episode just like always, but…I don’t know. I guess my expectations have disappeared almost entirely.
You see, the thing I loved about the reboot of Who was the emotional depth that Davies and his crew infused into what used to be nothing more than an adventure show. In the old Who, the Doctor was a classic cowboy figure. He road his TARDIS around time and space, finding lawless places that needed a ’sheriff’ and solving their problems with as little violence as possible. He may have had traveling companions, but their emotional bond was always platonic and the Doctor always seemed satisfied just by looking forward to the next adventure.
The new doctor was very different. He had the same pacifist, hero streak and wanderlust as the old, but he was far more fallible, far more human. He fell in love, and that love caused him great pain and vulnerability. He made mistakes – some that cost innocent people their lives. For the first time, he started looking around the TARDIS and seeing how empty it was without anyone to share it with. He became an empathetic figure, and for that I loved him.
Series 4 tried to change that as much as possible. Oh, don’t get me wrong – David Tennant’s acting was still top notch and even his companion, Donna, ended up having a really neat character arc, despite how much crap I constantly gave her. What suffered, though, was the overall writing. I mean, there were stinkers in previous seasons, but not a whole crop of ‘em like this year. They were still enjoyable for the most part, but they lacked any emotional resonance whatsoever. The Doctor became a Mary-Sue that could change the course of history just by showing up, macguffins were the rule of the day, and you could count on a Deus Ex Machina to rewrite space and time itself and undo the cliffhanger every single time. I mean, when everything goes right (and things that don’t are telegraphed sometimes two, three episodes in advance), where are the stakes? Why should I care? And don’t even get me STARTED on how Russell T. Davies resolved the Doctor/Rose saga, something I cared DEEPLY about and which came to a conclusion in yesterday’s episode that felt as though it were scribbled down by a twelve-year-old fanfic writer.
Also, there were no cybermen this year. Of course, if there was a series 4 cyberman episode, it would have gone a little something like this:
RAGE OF THE CYBERMEN
A PROPOSED SERIES FOUR EPISODE OF DOCTOR WHO BY CHAS R. ANDRES
FADE IN:
EXT. LONDON – DAY.
An IMPERTINENT LONDONER is walking around somewhere near the Thames, talking on his bluetooth headset.
IMPTERNINENT LONDONER
Yeah, yeah, I’m faxing the forms over right away over the wireless uplink. I’m sure glad that my crippling addition to technology will never act as a blunt metaphor for man’s dependence on machines.
Suddenly, a CYBERMAN whacks him over the head, killing him instantly.
ROLL CREDITS
EXT. LONDON – DAY.
The Doctor and Donna exit the TARDIS in a back alley behind the same apartment complex that most of the companions live in.
Cybermen are everywhere, whacking people over the head and turning them into cybermen, too.
DONNA
(huffy)
You told me that the cybermen were trapped in an alternate dimension and could never, ever, EVER get free. Ever!
DOCTOR
And yet here they are. Brilliant!
The Doctor runs off.
DONNA
Doctorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!
EXT. FRONT OF BUCKINGHAM PALACE OR SOMETHING – DAY.
The Doctor walks up to a cyberman and knocks on his breastplate.
DOCTOR
You there. Care to tell me what’s going on?
CYBERMAN
We came from the alternate dimension that you closed up forever because in this series forever is equal to about half a season. Also, the fabric of space and time is rapidly deteriorating.
DOCTOR
That’s no good.
CYBERMAN
Don’t worry. There’s probably some glowing red crystal that destroys us and resets the universe. I bet it’s really easy to find, too. Just bluster around until you find the cybercontroller.
DOCTOR
Awesome, thanks!
INT. CYBERCONTROLLER’S HUT MADE OF SILVER TUBES – DAY.
The Cybercontroller is about to make Donna into a cyberman. The doctor glares really angrily at the cybercontroller.
CYBERCONTROLLER
AND THAT IS HOW MY LASER WILL DESTROY EVERYTHING IN EVERY UNIVERSE – EVER!
DOCTOR
You can’t do this! Surely there is some little bit of humanity left inside you!
CYBERCONTROLLER
NEGATIVE. I AM PROGRAMMED ONLY TO KILL.
DOCTOR
What if I bat my eyelashes?
CYBERCONTROLLER
BEEP BOOP CONFUSED WHAT ARE THESE EMOTIONS?
Donna uses her guile to escape and runs over to a console next to where the Doctor is standing.
DONNA
What button should I press?
DOCTOR
You’ll have to reroute the positronic membrane to set up a feedback loop of argon-helium antlions in the cybermen’s discrete memory.
DONNA
How do I do that?
DOCTOR
Press that big red button and lift that really convenient switch.
Donna DOES.
CYBERCONTROLLER
NOOOO! MY BRAIN IS TOO FULL OF ANTLIONS. WHY DOCTOR WHY?
DOCTOR
You don’t have to die, cybercontroller. Even though you tried to destroy humanity, I will spare your life because I’m that sort of righteous dude. Just take my hand.
CYBERCONTROLLER
(shorting out)
TOO. MANY. ANT. LIONS.
DOCTOR
(yelling)
TAKE. MY. HAAAAND!
The Cybercontroller EXPLODES. The Doctor and Donna get back on the TARDIS just in time.
DONNA
You saved everyone, doctor! You were brilliant!
The Doctor stares off into space, darkly.
DOCTOR
I was brilliant…real brilliant.
He looks down at the floor.
DOCTOR (CONT’D)
But not brilliant enough.
END.